Stanley's blog

Peace between the Israelis and Palestinians is further away than ever. Animosity between Westerners and Muslims continues to grow. Traditional anti-Semitism is on the rise.

The composition of the current Israeli government is frightening. Prime Minister Netanyahu does not acknowledge a two state solution. Foreign Minister Lieberman continues to express his contempt for his Arab citizens and neighbours.

Most Jews in the Diaspora are probably unhappy with the present government. Should they speak out?

This poses a fundamental dilemma. Jews have suffered from anti-Semitism for two millennia. Israel has a special meaning for every confessed Jew, whether religious or secular. I can never forget the taunts in England before 1948, such as: “Go back to where you came from.” I felt like a “wandering Jew” with no homeland. After the establishment of the State of Israel, we became to our neighbours Jews with a homeland but who chose to live in England.

We believed in Israel, supported Israel and were proud of Israel. The Jews of the Diaspora closely associated themselves with Israel. They never publicly criticized Israeli government policies. I felt the same way.

Today the Israeli government position is unacceptable. There are at least two points of view on every aspect of the Israeli-Palestinian dispute, except one – the West Bank settlements. These have been built on land not belonging to Israel or the settlers. They have broken up the West Bank and have caused the fence to be built in a manner which has ruined the daily lives of many thousands of Palestinians. There is no legal justification for the settlements – only an extreme religious argument. Successive Israeli governments have permitted the steady, illegal expansion of the settlements.

Not only is there little prospect of peace under a Netanyahu government, but a lasting peace may no longer become possible.

During the last decades, the Jewish Diaspora, as a whole, has not spoken out for a just peace and against Israeli policies preventing it. Only a few lonely voices have done so and had heaped on them the disapproval of the majority. I admit not to have spoken out sufficiently. My late father’s words: “There are enough anti-Semites in the world without Jewish ones”, echo in my ears, however irrational the sentiment.

And yet, I feel that we are seeing policies and actions which are leading to the moral degradation of the Jewish people. Our values have underpinned society for millennia, and been adopted by Christians. The New Testament cannot stand up without the Old Testament.

Current Israeli government’s policy is not only unconscionable but it is not in Israel’s interests. The US Administration, led by Obama, will not tolerate indefinitely an attitude which does not genuinely indicate a desire for peace on equitable terms.

And extremists are gaining strength on both sides.

Only American Jewry has any real influence on Israel. So the best we European Jews can do is to express our views to our US brethren.

Author :


  1. It could be useful to recall that on 29 November 1947 the UN General Assembly voted to split the territory of Palestine into two entities to become two states, one for the Jews and one for the Arabs. It may be relevant reading the various books that Dominique Vidal has published on the Israel-Palestine issues. Unfortunately the majority of the Jewish Diaspora has been too resilient in supporting only its own legitimate cause even after the Rabin-Arafat talks in September 1993.

    [WORDPRESS HASHCASH] The poster sent us ‘1055386704 which is not a hashcash value.

  2. Dear Stanley,
    At last someone is speaking up! And you do it beautifully, with great restraint.
    But please put your words into letters addressed to the Washington Post, the New Yorker, Time magazine, etc whatever is read by the considerable numbers of Jewish US citizens who must be sharing your thoughts. It’s always the first letter that gets the hate mail, but the tenth letter that gets the “Me too” response. They need to hammer home to Congress and the Senate that the Obama-style US no longer skips and jumps whenever Israel starts piping.

    On the land division issue, wasn’t it originally just 56% to the new Israel and the proportion has now crept up to over 80% nowadays? Correct me if I’m wrong.

    [WORDPRESS HASHCASH] The poster sent us ‘1055386704 which is not a hashcash value.

Comments are closed.